a decent winter coat.
I could hear her.
So clearly
it almost hurt
like touch.
At the bottom,
beneath her signature,
she had added
one final instruction.
Tell Tyler
the cup was already chipped.
I had forgotten that.
Or perhaps
I had never known.
I drove home
with the envelope
on the passenger seat.
At a red light,
I began crying again.
Not because
another secret
had wounded us.
Because this one
had been waiting
to make something gentler.
Tyler read
his grandmother’s message
at the kitchen table.
He went over
the last line twice.
“It was?”
“Apparently.”
“She never told me.”
“I think
she wanted you
to stop apologizing.”
He stared
out the window
at the maple tree.
Then he laughed.
A small,
astonished sound.
“All that time
I thought
I broke her favorite thing.”
I touched
the edge of the page.
“You were never
her favorite thing.”